64 Hanmer St E, Barrie, ON L4M 6V6
Call Us : 249-288-3378
Ask For A Quote Email Us Now
Call Us : 249-288-3378
Ask For A Quote Email Us Now
One homeowner might descale the kettle every few weeks and wonder why the shower glass never looks clean. Another family might have someone on a sodium-restricted diet. A property manager might hear from tenants that their laundry comes out stiff. At Townhouse Plumbing, our answer for all three starts in the same place. A water softener is worth it when your water tests hard enough to leave scale you keep dealing with, and when you have a plan for the sodium a standard softener adds.
Two things move that answer more than anything a sales sheet says: the hardness number at your own tap, and whether the kitchen tap can stay on unsoftened water for whoever drinks from it. If the water tests under 50 mg/L, or someone must limit sodium and a separate drinking tap is not practical, the case for a softener gets weak quickly.
Hardness is the amount of dissolved calcium and magnesium in the water. Labs and water utilities usually report it in milligrams per litre as calcium carbonate, written mg/L. Some test kits and softener labels use grains per gallon instead, so check which unit a result is in before you compare it with anything in this guide.
Health Canada’s guideline on hardness gives a useful scale for this decision:
| Hardness, mg/L | What Health Canada’s guideline says | What it means for the decision |
|---|---|---|
| 80 to 100 | Suggested in the literature it cites as an acceptable balance between corrosion and incrustation | Above the 50 mg/L line where we think a softener is justifiable |
| Above 200 | Considered poor, but tolerated by consumers | Scale problems are likely, and a softener earns its place |
| Above 500 | Unacceptable for many domestic purposes, may require softening | A softener deserves serious thought |
| Above 750 | In rare instances, calcium exposure could exceed the health-based value | A band where hardness itself raises a health question |
In our judgment, a softener is justifiable once your water tests at 50 mg/L (about 3 grains per gallon) or higher. Above 200 mg/L, the guideline calls the water poor, and the case for a softener gets stronger.
Barrie’s municipal water does not come from one source. The City’s 2025 drinking water annual report describes a system made up of a surface water treatment plant and 12 groundwater wells. Surface water and well water may carry different amounts of minerals, so the hardness at your tap may depend on which part of the system feeds your street. Which part feeds yours?
A friend across town who likes their softener is not a reason to buy one. Test your own water, or ask the City’s water operations staff what the source serving your address usually measures before you decide anything. If your home is on a private well, you need your own test either way.
Health Canada’s guideline says that hard water requires a considerable amount of soap to produce a lather, and that it also causes scaling of hot water pipes, boilers and other household appliances. In areas with hard water, the guideline adds, household pipes can become clogged with scale.
Each warning sign in the house points to the same minerals. White crust on an aerator is the same mineral that can form inside the pipes behind it. Scale in the kettle shows you what is building up in anything else that heats water. Soap that will not lather means you use more of it with every load and every shower. Laundry that feels rough is the same hard water showing up in the laundry room.
Our water softener page lists the same effects: mineral buildup on fixtures, a shorter life for appliances, laundry that feels rough and extra strain on the plumbing system. The guideline places that scale on the inside of hot water pipes and water heating appliances. In our view, scale you cannot see is worth planning for.
We would rather you buy only what your home needs. If your test comes back under 50 mg/L and you see few of these signs, a softener mostly solves a problem you do not have. If scale has already caused a drip at a fixture or a valve, our leak repair in Barrie page explains how we handle it.
A softener is not free of trade-offs, and they deserve as much attention as the scale.
A standard softener trades the calcium and magnesium in your water for sodium. Health Canada advises that people on sodium-restricted diets should be aware that residential softening systems increase the sodium concentration in the treated water. The same guideline says that, generally, children under 8 should not drink water containing sodium from a water softener, as they may exceed the recommended upper limit of 1.5 to 1.9 g of sodium a day.
Barrie’s water already carries some sodium before any softener touches it. The sampling table in the City’s report shows sodium from 9.6 mg/L at one well to 136 mg/L at another. A softener adds to whatever your source water already has.
How soft should the water be? A standard softener takes nearly all of the hardness out, and not every unit can leave some in. The 80 to 100 mg/L balance that the guideline cites from the literature weighs corrosion against scale. Ask whether the system you are offered has a blending valve that leaves a little hardness in the water, not only whether it softens.
A softener also needs salt and a drain. It cleans itself in a cycle called regeneration, and the guideline notes that these units typically regenerate with a sodium chloride or potassium chloride brine, which adds chlorides to the waste water. You take on topping up the salt for as long as you own the unit.
A softener installed with no bypass to the kitchen tap looks fine on the first day. The water runs, the soap lathers and nobody notices a change at the sink. The added sodium is in every glass of water from then on, and nothing about the tap tells you so.
For most homes, hardness is about scale, soap and appliances rather than health. The guideline raises a health question about hardness itself only in rare instances above 750 mg/L. The drinking question runs the other way, because the sodium from the softener is the thing to plan for.
Health Canada recommends that a portion of the water most frequently consumed, such as the kitchen tap, bypass the softener altogether to avoid excessive sodium or potassium intake. You keep softened water for showers and laundry, and unsoftened water for drinking and cooking.
For lowering hardness itself, Health Canada’s guideline says water softeners are the best available technology for the overall reduction of hardness, calcium and magnesium.
Two alternatives are worth knowing about before you buy. A softener that regenerates with potassium chloride works the same way but adds potassium in place of sodium. The guideline’s bypass advice names potassium as well, so the kitchen tap bypass still makes sense with one. The other is a filter or conditioner sold as salt-free. What does it remove, and does it lower the hardness number on a test? If the number does not change, it is not doing what a softener does.
A softener is likely worth it when:
It is likely not worth it, or not yet, when:
A softener connects to your main water supply, so the plumbing around it matters as much as the unit itself. When we come out for a softener job, we carefully inspect the problem, explain exactly what we find, answer your questions and recommend what makes sense for your home and your budget.
Before any work starts, settle these points with whoever installs it:
Our page on water softener installation in Barrie lists what that service covers, from new installs to replacements, upgrades and the plumbing connections for softener systems.
Homeowners and property managers can start the same way. Get your hardness number first, then contact us with it and tell us about your house. At Townhouse Plumbing, our goal is not one installed softener. It is a long term relationship with a plumbing company you can rely on whenever the need arises.
It adds sodium to the water you drink unless a tap bypasses it. It needs salt and a drain for regeneration, and it becomes one more appliance to maintain.
Hardness is rarely a health issue for drinking. Health Canada raises a calcium concern only in rare instances above 750 mg/L. Softened water carries added sodium, so the guideline recommends keeping the kitchen tap on unsoftened water, and it advises that children under 8 generally should not drink water containing sodium from a softener, as they may exceed the recommended upper limit of 1.5 to 1.9 g of sodium a day.
On hard water, yes, because it lowers the minerals that form scale on fixtures and inside hot water pipes and appliances. On water that tests under 50 mg/L, the difference is small, and the test tells you which case you are in.
At Townhouse Plumbing, a water softener starts at $1,800. The final price depends on the unit you choose and on the plumbing around your main shut off valve.
Test it, because a home test kit or a lab test gives you a number in mg/L or grains per gallon. White scale on fixtures and inside the kettle is a strong hint, but only the number tells you how hard the water is and whether a softener earns its place.
Leave A Comment